Writing · Editing · Making booksAbout the journal ↗
into publishing

Writing

Separate what a character wants from what they need

A character can pursue a clear objective while misunderstanding the change that would make their life different.

Two character-planning cards distinguish winning an audition from learning to accept help.

Start with the pursuit

A character's want is useful because it gives them something to do. They want a particular job, their sister's forgiveness, a room of their own or the return of a borrowed object. Readers can follow attempts toward a defined result. A vague desire to be happy gives the writer fewer opportunities to show choice and resistance.

For an illustrative character, consider a musician determined to win an audition. The audition is the immediate objective. She practises, seeks a reference and decides whether to conceal an injury. These actions let the story test her rather than merely describing ambition. Write the objective on a note card in ordinary language. If you cannot imagine an observable success or failure, make it more specific.

What the character needs is a different question. Perhaps she treats every offer of help as proof that she is inadequate. Learning to accept support could matter more to her long-term life than the audition result. The need does not have to be a moral lesson, and you do not have to label it in the manuscript. It can be a missing capacity, an unexamined belief or a truth she resists.

Make the two pressures meet

The distinction becomes dramatic when pursuit exposes the underlying problem. If our musician can win the audition without ever confronting her refusal of help, the need may remain an essay attached to the plot. Give her a situation where an effective step toward the want requires the behaviour she avoids. She might need to tell a colleague why she cannot manage a passage alone.

Do not make that solution effortless. Accepting help may risk a reputation she has carefully built, or require admitting that earlier advice was sound. The character should have a reason for maintaining the old habit. Otherwise the story becomes a sequence of people explaining an obvious lesson to someone who refuses to listen.

A want can also change. Learning what the job entails may make the musician reconsider it. That is different from abandoning the goal because the plot has become inconvenient. Show the discovery and the cost of changing course. Readers can follow a revised objective when they understand what made the earlier one inadequate.

Leave room for an imperfect ending

Winning does not prove that a character has changed, and losing does not prove that they have learned. Test the ending through behaviour. If the musician loses but calls the colleague she once dismissed, that action may complete one movement while leaving another unresolved. If she wins and continues hiding every difficulty, success can expose the persistence of her problem.

Not every story needs a clean want-versus-need diagram. Some characters understand themselves well; others choose to preserve a belief despite its cost. Use the distinction when it clarifies choices, not as a requirement to manufacture an arc. The useful test is whether the character's pursuit reveals something about the way they live. A note card can help you plan that relationship, but the scenes must make it felt.

Send a correction or a question about this article.