Writing · Editing · Making booksAbout the journal ↗
into publishing

Editing

Hand a manuscript to an editor without version confusion

A clear handover gives an editor one authoritative manuscript and a short account of what the assignment covers.

Clipboard, notebooks and folders arranged for a document handover

Send one recognisable master

Choose the manuscript that is ready for the agreed work and give it an unambiguous filename. A title, date and stage are usually more useful than a chain of “final”, “new” and “latest”. Open the actual file you will send and inspect its beginning, ending and chapter sequence. An attachment selected from an old folder can undo an otherwise careful handover.

Send the whole manuscript unless a different arrangement has been agreed. Separate chapter files may suit some workflows, but they need a clear sequence and a record of what is included. Label reference material as reference material. An editor should not have to infer whether an alternative ending is a proposal, background information or the version to edit.

Add a brief that resolves uncertainty

State the kind of work agreed, the intended reader and any decisions already made. Include a style sheet if one exists. Highlight genuinely unresolved matters, such as a placeholder quotation or a chapter awaiting a fact check. A short, specific note is more useful than a long account of every difficulty encountered while writing.

Explain how revisions and queries should move between you. Confirm the file format, how changes will be shown and where questions should be answered. If another contributor can approve changes, identify that role. The editor needs a route to an authoritative answer, particularly when collaborators disagree.

Keep schedules explicit without assuming that every date is interchangeable. Delivery of an edited manuscript, your response and the final handover may be separate milestones. Record the arrangement somewhere both parties can find it.

Freeze the handed-over version

Once work begins, resist editing the same master independently. Put new ideas in a separate note and discuss any urgent correction through the agreed channel. Sending a replacement file halfway through an edit can require comparison and reconciliation, even when only a few paragraphs changed.

Retain a copy of exactly what was sent, with its accompanying brief. When the edited version returns, save that separately before reviewing it. The goal is a short, traceable sequence of versions in which each file has a purpose. That record saves time when a later question depends on what the manuscript actually said at handover.

Send a correction or a question about this article.